Polemology Positions

Share this post

Jakarta Methods: The Full Series on Indonesian Genocide, 1965-1966

www.polemology.net

Jakarta Methods: The Full Series on Indonesian Genocide, 1965-1966

An annotated link post

Matt Osborne
Nov 22, 2021
1
Share this post

Jakarta Methods: The Full Series on Indonesian Genocide, 1965-1966

www.polemology.net

One of my projects this fall has been a historical analysis of the Indonesian genocide. Informed by the literature on pre-state modes of warfare, I set out to contextualize the systematic murder of 500,000-1.5 million people within the modes of political violence that were familiar to the killers, with full appreciation for the role of western policy in the slaughter. Thanks to American transfer, “disappearances” and death squads — “Jakarta methods” — became the primary modes of anti-leftist violence in Central and South America. Right wing forces throughout the Americas issued coded threats; “Jakarta is coming” was a common graffiti slogan in Santiago on the eve of Pinochet’s coup.

While the final product is organized with this order mostly reversed, each post here represents the discrete first draft of one portion, so I am leaving them in chronological order.

Polemology Positions
Suharto's War of the Sexes and the Indonesian Genocide of 1965
In the image above, Suharto becomes a literal father to the Indonesian nation by straightening out all the naughty transgressive women with the deft use of armed force, turning them into proper baby machines for the state. This scene is on the plinth of the monument to the dead generals of 1965 at Lubang Buaya. (Photo credit to…
Read more
a year ago · 1 like · Matt Osborne

Sukarno provides a perfect point of departure for radical feminist arguments in favor of female separatism, especially in regards to political organizing. As long as men decide the fate of women’s issues, women’s organizing will always walk one step behind and to the side of whatever patriarchy values more.

Polemology Positions
When the Army of Indonesia Declared War on the Army of Durable Girls
Of the stories I’ve read so far in my ongoing research of Suharto’s genocide, the most awful all involve women and children. Special horrors meted out to these victims share an appalling theme of hatred. Pregnant women identified as communists were murdered, often butchered, fetuses dismembered; new mothers were killed along with their infants; toddlers…
Read more
a year ago · 2 likes · Matt Osborne

I am also a keen student of radio warfare history, and Indonesia qualifies as the world’s first radio-powered genocide.

Polemology Positions
A Secret History of the Indonesian Genocide
In an effort to keep their Holocaust a secret, the Nazi extermination program sent and received orders by landline wire communications, which were more secure than wireless. A radio station inside of a death camp would be inviting another Sobibor uprising, except the prisoners would be sending out messages to the world instead of blowing up a gas chambe…
Read more
a year ago · 1 like · Matt Osborne

The spark that lit the Indonesian powder keg was a poorly-planned coup by communist officers in the Indonesian Army. It is a complex story, with some elements that remain mysterious to this day, so I wanted to untangle the important narrative threads in a single post.

Polemology Positions
The Timeline of Suharto's Witch Hunt
When Lt. Colonel Untung bin Sjamsuri informed the country of his pre-emptive counter-coup against a supposed ”Council of Generals” that had been in cahoots with the CIA on the morning of October 1, 1965, he charged senior Army officers with corruption, elitism, and “insulting” or…
Read more
a year ago · Matt Osborne

Another post was necessary to untangle the political history of Sukarno and the Old Order. Like most Americans, I knew almost nothing about this topic when I chose it.

Polemology Positions
Guided Democracy: Sukarno's Impossible Country
My political geography professor called Indonesia “the impossible country.” Three thousand miles from end to end, with hundreds of large and thousands of small islands, many languages and thousands of dialects, and hundreds if not thousands of micro-identities within six major ethnic groups, the Indonesian state fits no naturalistic theory of state form…
Read more
a year ago · 1 like · 2 comments · Matt Osborne

Finally, the piece-de-resistance: a chance to apply all the anthropology, ethnography, and archaeology I have been reading in my study of primitive warfare. On the island of Bali, the Army issued traditional klewang swords (the diagonal blades in the photo above) to militiamen for their nocturnal dirty work killing communist prisoners.

Polemology Positions
Suharto the Headhunter
We are familiar with the medieval trope of heads on pikes and the revolutionary guillotine lopping off aristocratic heads. Social science calls this sort of public display “exemplary punishment.” The spectacle…
Read more
a year ago · Matt Osborne

This has been Phase One of my genocide studies. In Phase Two, I want to look at another impossible country, one that shows disturbing signs of coming apart at the seams. What would genocide look like in the United States? How real is the possibility? What are the independent variables that matter? Rather than a single scenario, I plan to offer realistic possible futures along a few different negative trend lines.

Share this post

Jakarta Methods: The Full Series on Indonesian Genocide, 1965-1966

www.polemology.net
Comments
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Polemology Positions
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing