Polemology Positions

Share this post

A Shield-Bearing Slave in Comic Relief

www.polemology.net

A Shield-Bearing Slave in Comic Relief

Hoplite humor from ancient Athens

Matt Osborne
Aug 24, 2022
3
Share this post

A Shield-Bearing Slave in Comic Relief

www.polemology.net
Gregarious masters are the most exhausting

Sculpted of marble from Mount Pentelicus, this loutrophoros was unearthed at the ancient port of Piraeus. The term literally translates as “bath-water carrier.” Most of these long-necked, two-handled pottery vessels have been found in pieces at the demosion sema, or public cemetery of Athens. Funerals and wedding baths seem to have been their primary ceremonial uses.

As they were painted by an exclusive handful of artisan families, however, these were also status symbols. For example, many loutrophori feature hunters and cavalry riders, preoccupations of the gentry. Frequently, citizens of this equestrian class would ostentatiously dismount to fight with the infantry as a hoplite, but their noble blood still demanded an elevated image in death.

Polemology Positions is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a paid subscriber.

Our example features two hoplites meeting on foot at some sort of muster. Both men are equipped with sword and breastplate. However, Polystratos, the man remembered in the center, is not wearing his helmet or carrying his shield. Instead, his slave stands behind him bearing both burdens. Smaller than either citizen, he is barely any larger than the shield he carries. That hardly seems accidental. In fact, it strikes me as essential to the piece.

The beard over the edge of the hoplon looks objectively silly

The word for any ancient shield in ancient Greek was aspis. When a hoplite — that is, a full citizen of the city-state — carried an aspis as part of the panoply, it became a hoplon. Most hoplons weighed 15 pounds or more (about 7 kg), but we can assume a very large, strong man with means would carry a large, solid shield, perhaps 20 lbs (roughly 9 kg) or more. For a very small person, that might be a lot to hold up after a while. His expression reminds me of Tyrtaeus, the Spartan poet, calling on warriors to grit their teeth for battle.

Polemology Positions
Meet the Actual Spartans
The Bronze Lie: Shattering the Myth of Spartan Warrior Supremacy. Osprey Publishing, 2021. 615 pages. Above: the Chigi vase, which depicts Spartans that look very unlike our modern filmic ones. “One on one,” author Myke Cole tells us of the Spartans, “they weren’t particularly tough, but…their ability to fight together as a disciplined unit far exceeded t…
Read more
a year ago · 1 like · Matt Osborne

Contrary to the images projected by comic book art and the films derived from it, there was no uniformity whatsoever to the hoplite panoply. Shields and breastplates and helmets were as varied as the men who wore them. I am no expert on ancient Greek helmets, but this one is evdently tall, and therefore meant to be seen above the fray. It also appears to be cinched overtight to fit around the smaller man’s head.

He looks disgruntled to me. Like a camel. Or is that determination?

While the motif of hoplite and shield-bearing slave is not uncommon in loutrophori, the artist was clearly striving for comic effect here. A slapstick joke was encoded in the hierarchy of arms and men, and communicated to the future.

Known as the Loutrophoros of Polystratos, this object is on display at the National Art Museum of Athens. It is positioned on the left in the photo below. Like the poetic comedies of Aristophanes performed in the Theatre of Dionysus, where the young men of Athens also graduated basic training, it was meant to make an audience laugh, and that laughter was not at all cheap. Polystratos was town, but still upper class. He could afford to have laughter at his own funeral.

Polemology Positions is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a paid subscriber.

Share this post

A Shield-Bearing Slave in Comic Relief

www.polemology.net
Comments
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Polemology Positions
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing