Polemology Positions

Share this post

A Serious Question For You, Dear Reader

www.polemology.net

A Serious Question For You, Dear Reader

Don't worry, just a quick poll

Matt Osborne
Dec 11, 2022
3
2
Share this post

A Serious Question For You, Dear Reader

www.polemology.net
Apprehensive Pikemen at a reenactment of the Siege of Basi… | Flickr

As I knuckled down on a compliation draft of my first thesis chapters, I suddenly had the notion to try a Twitter poll. It’s still open for a few hours if you want to participate.

It does not matter what level of education you have attained or where you live or were educated. No matter who you are, if you can read this sentence in English, then please do take part in my poll.

Twitter avatar for @polemologyfix
Polemology Positions @polemologyfix
Survey! For a thing! Really, not kidding! Did anyone, at any point in your personal education, whatever level of achievement, public or private, mention the English Civil War(s) 1638-1660 in any way, shape, or form, related to civics, government, history, "social studies," etc?
7:20 AM ∙ Dec 11, 2022
3Likes1Retweet

Get a group subscription

Since not all of my subscribers are on Twitter, here is a Substack poll asking the same question in a less early-AM-after-writing-historiography-all-day wording.

If you took part in the Twitter poll, feel free to ignore this. If you prefer to answer here, then please ignore the Twitter poll. This one will be open for 72 hours.

Loading...

Give a gift subscription

For my closing argument, I would like to present a snapshot, however imperfect or small, of “market awareness” of the conflict I have studied so much.

Advertisers test out keywords for consumer response online every day. A sales pitch for better public education about these wars must derive from an informed understanding of where the public already stands in relation to them.

Mileage will of course vary. If the reader is Irish, for example, they will likely have opinions about these wars, to say nothing of Oliver Cromwell. Canadians and Americans may be less likely to recognize either.

But I don’t need that kind of granular detail. An aggregate response from the English-speaking world is fine, as it would not exist without the wars in question.

Thanks in advance for your responses.

Polemology Positions is a reader-supported publication. Subscribe to support my work

2
Share this post

A Serious Question For You, Dear Reader

www.polemology.net
2 Comments
Paul Black
Dec 11, 2022Liked by Matt Osborne

So, in the UK, back when I where a lad (we used to wear an onion in our belt, which was the style at the time, etc) we were taught about the Civil war, but only in a very surface level, low detail way.

Little to no depth beyond King Charles I gone, Charles II hiding in an oak tree, Oliver Cromwell in charge. Don’t think the Battle Of Edgehill was even mentioned.

Would absolutely be interested in a more in depth look, especially since your profile on John Fowke appears to suggest it was the consequence of a feud between some jumped up little upstart who was getting too big for his boots …and John Fowke.

Expand full comment
ReplyCollapse
1 reply by Matt Osborne
1 more comment…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Polemology Positions
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing